Intended Parents

How Surrogate Screening Through a Surrogacy Agency Safeguards Your Journey


Proper surrogate screening can be the difference between starting life with your new family and waiting longer to become a parent.

When you work with a reputable surrogacy agency, comprehensive screening processes protect both you and your surrogate, ensuring the best possible foundation for your journey ahead.

We’re here to walk you through exactly how surrogate screening works, why it matters so much for your success, and what red flags to watch for when choosing an agency.

What if you could eliminate months of uncertainty and move forward with complete confidence in your surrogate match?

Schedule a consultation today to learn how thorough screening process’ can accelerate your path to parenthood.

How Do Surrogacy Agencies Screen Surrogates?

Surrogate screening is a multi-step process designed to ensure that potential surrogates are physically, emotionally, and financially prepared for the surrogacy journey.

Reputable agencies follow a systematic approach that includes meeting preliminary requirements, conducting social assessments, reviewing medical records and insurance, performing background checks, completing psychological evaluations, and coordinating fertility clinic screenings.

This comprehensive process typically takes several weeks to complete and serves as a crucial safeguard for intended parents. Understanding how surrogates are screened helps you appreciate why working with an experienced agency is so valuable—they have the expertise to identify the best candidates while protecting your interests throughout the process.

The screening process begins the moment a woman expresses interest in becoming a surrogate and continues until she receives full clearance from both the agency and the fertility clinic. Only after complete approval does she become available for matching with intended parents.

Meeting Preliminary Surrogacy Agency Requirements

The American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) provides comprehensive guidelines for gestational carrier screening that reputable agencies use as their foundation.

 According to ASRM recommendations, women who want to become surrogates should meet the following requirements:

  • Age between 21-45 years old to ensure physical and emotional maturity

  • Previous successful pregnancy and delivery with uncomplicated outcomes

  • Body Mass Index (BMI) within healthy range to reduce pregnancy complications

  • Stable living situation with adequate housing and support system

  • Financial stability independent of surrogate compensation

  • No history of substance abuse including tobacco, alcohol, and illegal drugs

  • Mental health stability with no untreated psychological conditions

  • Ability to commit to the full surrogacy process including medical appointments and lifestyle modifications

  • Legal capacity to enter into binding contracts

     

  • Access to reliable transportation for medical appointments and screenings

    These preliminary requirements serve as the first filter in the screening process. Agencies that follow ASRM guidelines help ensure that only qualified candidates move forward to more detailed screening steps.

    Review: Social Questionnaire, Medical Records and Insurance, Background Check

    Once a potential surrogate meets the basic requirements, agencies conduct an in-depth review of three critical areas that provide insight into her suitability for surrogacy.

    An extensive document that explores a woman\'s motivations for becoming a surrogate, her family dynamics, support system, and lifestyle factors. This questionnaire helps agencies understand whether she has realistic expectations about the surrogacy process and the emotional resilience needed to navigate the journey successfully. Questions cover everything from her relationship with her partner to her previous pregnancy experiences and her comfort level with medical procedures.

    This review involves examining the surrogate\'s complete obstetric history, including prenatal care, delivery records, and postpartum recovery from previous pregnancies. The surrogate screening process also includes verification of current health insurance coverage and confirmation that her policy will cover pregnancy-related expenses. This step is crucial because insurance complications can derail a surrogacy journey and create unexpected financial burdens.

    Provides essential information about a potential surrogate\'s criminal history, financial stability, and overall reliability. These checks protect intended parents from potential risks and help ensure that their surrogate can fulfill her commitments throughout the pregnancy. Agencies look for any red flags that might indicate problems with reliability, honesty, or legal compliance.

    Psychological Evaluation

    The psychological evaluation represents one of the most important components of surrogate screening. This comprehensive assessment, conducted by a licensed mental health professional with expertise in reproductive psychology, serves multiple crucial purposes in protecting both intended parents and surrogates.

    Key aspects of surrogate screening include evaluating the potential surrogate’s emotional readiness for the unique challenges of carrying someone else’s child. The evaluation assesses her ability to form appropriate boundaries with intended parents while maintaining the collaborative relationship necessary for a successful journey.

    Mental health professionals also examine the surrogate’s coping mechanisms, stress management abilities, and support systems.

    They want to understand how she has handled previous challenges and whether she has the emotional tools needed to navigate the ups and downs of pregnancy while managing the complex dynamics inherent in surrogacy relationships.

    The psychological evaluation also screens for any underlying mental health conditions that could impact the pregnancy or the surrogacy relationship.

    This isn’t about excluding women with mental health histories, but rather ensuring that any conditions are properly managed and won’t create risks for the pregnancy or complications in the relationship with intended parents.

    Surrogate Screening With an Agency vs. Without: Risk Comparison

    Working with an experienced surrogacy agency provides significant advantages when it comes to screening surrogates compared to attempting to find and screen a surrogate independently. Agencies bring years of expertise, established protocols, and professional networks that individual intended parents simply cannot replicate on their own.

    When intended parents try to find surrogates independently, they face numerous risks that can lead to devastating delays and complications.

    Without professional screening expertise, it’s easy to miss critical red flags or fail to ask the right questions during the evaluation process. This can result in matches with unqualified surrogates who may not be physically, emotionally, or financially prepared for the journey ahead.

    Scam risks increase dramatically when intended parents work outside of established agency frameworks.

    Dishonest individuals may misrepresent their qualifications, medical history, or intentions, leading to financial losses and emotional devastation. Agencies have systems in place to verify information and protect intended parents from fraudulent schemes.

    Perhaps most importantly, working with an agency provides access to pre-screened, qualified surrogates who have already undergone comprehensive evaluation.

    If complications arise or rematch becomes necessary, agencies have backup options available, whereas independent intended parents may face months of additional searching and screening.

    Red Flags: When Screening Is Superficial

    Not all surrogacy agencies maintain the same standards when it comes to surrogate screening, and some concerning practices can put intended parents at significant risk. Understanding these red flags helps you identify agencies that prioritize quick matches over thorough screening processes.

    One of the most serious warning signs is when agencies make surrogates available for matching before completing full screening clearance.

    The best agencies won’t clear a surrogate until all prescreening components are complete, including psychological evaluation, medical records review, background checks, and social assessment. Only after receiving full clearance does the surrogate undergo clinic screening when a matching opportunity arises.

    Hasty agencies often make their surrogates available after they meet only basic requirements, meaning intended parents could be matched with someone who later fails to qualify during more detailed screening.

    This approach leads to disappointment, delays, and the need for rematch situations that can add months to your journey.

    Other red flags include:

    • Rushing through psychological evaluations or using unqualified evaluators

    • Skipping comprehensive medical records review or accepting incomplete documentation

    • Failing to verify insurance coverage or ignoring potential coverage gaps

    • Inadequate background checks that don\'t reveal important information

    • Lack of transparency about screening processes or criteria

    • Pressure to match quickly without allowing time for proper due diligence

      Next Steps & Getting Professional Support

      Choosing the right surrogacy agency with comprehensive screening protocols is one of the most important decisions you’ll make on your path to parenthood. The screening process should feel thorough, transparent, and designed to protect your interests while ensuring the best possible foundation for your surrogacy journey.

      Don’t settle for agencies that treat you like just another number—you deserve support from professionals who understand the importance of thorough screening because they’ve seen the consequences when corners are cut.

      Speak with a specialist today to learn how the best surrogate screening process can give you confidence and peace of mind as you begin your surrogacy journey.

      Get Started