Get Started

Intended Parents

The Best Surrogacy Agencies When You Already Have a Surrogate

So you’ve found your surrogate—maybe she’s a friend, a family member, or someone you connected with through social networks.

Here’s what most people don’t realize: having a surrogate lined up is just the beginning.

Most families assume handling their own surrogacy will save money, but they’re often surprised to discover they’re still spending $30,000+ on attorneys, medical coordination, and surprise expenses, all while juggling the stress of managing every detail themselves.

Fill out our simple form to get more information about how surrogacy agencies can help you navigate your surrogacy journey if you already have a surrogate.

These agencies step in where you need them most, handling the complex stuff while letting you maintain the personal relationship you’ve already built.

Do I Need a Surrogacy Agency if I Already Found a Surrogate?

Most families benefit from agency involvement, even with a surrogate already in place. The question isn’t really whether you need help—it’s what kind of help makes sense for your situation.

The Real Cost of Independent Surrogacy with Your Own Surrogate

Independence comes with a price tag that surprises most families. Even with an unpaid surrogate and insurance coverage, you’re looking at substantial expenses.

These include:

More importantly, you’ll be managing relationships, medical logistics, and financial decisions during what should be an exciting time.

Many families find the stress overwhelming, especially when complications arise and they don’t have experienced advocates to guide them through.

Our Criteria for Evaluating Agencies for Identified Surrogate Arrangements

We evaluated agencies based on their actual track record with identified surrogate arrangements, not just their marketing materials. Our assessment focused on programs specifically designed for families who already have a surrogate:

From what we’ve seen, the right agency match can cut months off your timeline while helping you avoid the costly mistakes that often derail independent arrangements.

American Surrogacy: Our Top Pick for Complete Support

From our research, American Surrogacy developed their Independent Surrogacy Program specifically for families in your situation.

Instead of shoehorning you into their standard matching process, they created a distinct track that provides full-service coordination while respecting the relationship you’ve already established.

What sets them apart, in our assessment, is their understanding that identified surrogate arrangements have unique dynamics.

Your surrogate isn’t a stranger they matched you with—she’s someone you chose, with her own motivations and concerns. Their coordinators know how to work within existing relationships rather than trying to recreate their typical agency dynamic.

Why This Program Works

Based on our evaluation, their coordinators have seen every possible scenario with identified surrogates.

They know which conversations tend to get awkward (money discussions), which medical requirements surprise people (psychological evaluations for everyone), and where families typically hit roadblocks (insurance coverage verification).

Most importantly, they maintain relationships with reproductive attorneys in every state, so you’re not hunting for local lawyers who may or may not understand surrogacy law.

They also have established partnerships with major fertility clinics, which means smoother medical coordination and fewer delays.

What You Get:

Creative Family Connections: Streamlined Legal Focus

Creative Family Connections takes a different approach, focusing primarily on the legal and basic coordination aspects rather than full-service management.

This works well for families who feel confident handling day-to-day communication and logistics but want professional oversight for the complex legal components.

Their Specialized Approach

This agency appeals to detail-oriented families who enjoy being involved in the process but recognize they need expert help with contracts and compliance.

They’re particularly strong in states with complex surrogacy laws, where DIY approaches often run into legal complications.

Their attorneys specialize exclusively in reproductive law and stay current on rapidly changing state regulations. They also maintain basic medical coordination services to ensure your surrogate meets clinical requirements, but they won’t manage every aspect of your pregnancy journey.

What You Get:

Circle Surrogacy: Premium Coordination for Complex Cases

Circle Surrogacy’s identified surrogate program works best for families dealing with additional complexities—international clients, egg donor coordination, or unique medical situations that require extra oversight.

When Premium Services Make Sense

From our analysis, if your surrogacy involves multiple moving pieces beyond the basic arrangement, Circle’s comprehensive approach can be worth the higher investment. They excel at coordinating complex cases where standard programs might leave gaps.

Their strength lies in their established network of specialists: reproductive endocrinologists, maternal-fetal medicine doctors, reproductive attorneys, and donor coordinators who work together regularly.

For families needing egg donors alongside their identified surrogate, or dealing with international legal complications, this coordinated approach prevents delays and miscommunications.

What You Get:

What Can Go Wrong Without Professional Help

How Agency Involvement Protects Everyone

Making the Right Choice for Your Family

Finding your own surrogate puts you ahead of most families starting this journey, but based on our research, it doesn’t eliminate the need for experienced guidance.

Whether you want comprehensive coordination, focused legal services, or case management, working with an agency protects your journey.

Ready to explore how professional coordination can smooth your path to parenthood? Connect with us today to learn more about programs designed specifically for families who’ve already found their surrogate.

Get Started