The 5 Most Reputable Surrogacy Agencies for Intended Parents in 2025

Choosing the right surrogacy agency is one of the most important decisions intended parents will make on their journey to parenthood.

After analyzing financial protection, family-building experience and ratings and reviews, we’ve identified the five most reputable surrogacy agencies serving intended parents today.

Each of these most reputable surrogacy agencies excels in different areas, making them ideal for specific types of intended parents.

Ready to speak with a top-rated agency today? Consider starting with a free consultation to learn how you could be matched in as little as 1-4 months.

Quick Overview: Top 5 Surrogacy Agencies

• American Surrogacy – Best for Intended Parents Prioritizing Speed and Transparency
• ConceiveAbilities – Best for Intended Parents Seeking Egg Donor Services
• Circle Surrogacy – Best for International Intended Parents Seeking a Trusted U.S. Agency
• Alcea Surrogacy – Best for Intended Parents Seeking a Boutique Experience
• Growing Generations – Best for Intended Parents with a High Budget

Our Evaluation Criteria

We evaluated each of the most reputable surrogacy agencies based on five critical factors that matter most to intended parents:

• Ratings and Reviews – Real client feedback from multiple platforms to understand actual experiences rather than marketing claims.
• Financial Protection – Safeguards and guarantees that protect intended parents’ significant financial investment throughout the surrogacy process.
• Experience – Years in operation and staff expertise in navigating a variety of complex surrogacy arrangements.

1. American Surrogacy – Best for Intended Parents Prioritizing Speed and Transparency

American Surrogacy has built its reputation on eliminating the lengthy wait times that plague many competitors while maintaining rigorous screening standards.

Backed by over 30 years of family-building experience through their sister agency, American Adoptions, American Surrogacy brings proven expertise in helping intended parents navigate complex reproductive journeys.

Investment Range: $189,500-$200,000+

Key Advantages

• 1-4 month Wait Times – American Surrogacy delivers significantly faster wait times than industry averages. This speed comes from their proactive surrogate recruitment and pre-screening processes that maintain a ready pool of qualified candidates.
• Comprehensive Screening and Marketing – The agency handles all aspects of surrogate screening, from medical and psychological evaluations to background checks, while also managing marketing efforts to continuously expand their surrogate network.
• Limited Risk Program – Their signature financial protection program provides financial safeguards and guarantees that give intended parents peace of mind throughout the process, reducing the risk of failed matches or unexpected complications.

Considerations

• Premium Pricing Structure – The comprehensive service model and risk protections are reflected in higher fees, though many clients find the transparency and speed justify the investment.

Who American Surrogacy is Ideal For

American Surrogacy serves intended parents who have already waited long enough to build their families and prioritize efficiency without compromising quality.

 

Learn more about how American Surrogacy can help you become parents faster.

2. ConceiveAbilities – Best for Intended Parents Seeking Egg Donor Services

ConceiveAbilities has established itself among the most reputable surrogacy agencies as a leader in comprehensive reproductive services, particularly excelling in situations where intended parents need both surrogacy and egg donation services under one roof.

Investment Range: $197,500

Key Advantages

• Personalized Matching Approach – The agency takes a highly individualized approach to pairing intended parents with surrogates, considering personality compatibility alongside medical criteria.
• LGBTQ+ Inclusive Services – ConceiveAbilities has built strong expertise serving LGBTQ+ intended parents, understanding the unique legal and emotional considerations these families face.

Considerations

• Unclear Timeline Expectations – The agency doesn’t prominently display wait times on their website, and client reviews frequently mention longer-than-expected matching periods.
• Extended Wait Periods – Multiple client testimonials reference wait times that exceeded initial projections, which can be challenging for intended parents eager to move forward.

Who ConceiveAbilities is Ideal For

3. Circle Surrogacy – Best for International Intended Parents Seeking a Trusted U.S. Agency

Circle Surrogacy brings decades of experience to the surrogacy space and has developed particular expertise serving international intended parents navigating U.S. surrogacy laws and logistics.

As one of the most reputable surrogacy agencies with a long track record, they’ve refined their international service offerings.

Investment Range: $179,500

Key Advantages

• Comprehensive Egg Donor Services – Beyond surrogacy, Circle offers extensive egg donation programs, making them a one-stop solution for intended parents needing multiple reproductive services.
• Extensive Industry Experience – As one of the longer-established agencies, Circle has refined their processes through thousands of successful surrogacy arrangements.

Considerations

• Extended Wait Times – Client reviews consistently report wait times extending 18+ months, significantly longer than some competitors.
• Corporate Ownership Structure – The agency is owned by private equity group Cortec Group, which some intended parents prefer to know when selecting a provider.
• Screening Concerns – Some reviews mention instances of matches falling through due to screening issues that weren’t identified earlier in the process.

Who Circle Surrogacy is Ideal For

4. Alcea Surrogacy – Best for Intended Parents Seeking a Boutique Experience

Alcea Surrogacy differentiates itself among the most reputable surrogacy agencies through highly personalized service delivered by staff who have personal experience with surrogacy, either as former surrogates or intended parents themselves.

Investment Range: Approximately $125,000

Key Advantages

• Personal Experience-Based Staff – The team consists of individuals who have lived through surrogacy journeys, providing empathy and insight that purely professional staff cannot match.
• Community-Focused Discount Programs – Alcea offers meaningful discounts for frontline workers, medical professionals, teachers, social workers, and cancer survivors, making surrogacy more accessible to deserving families.

Considerations

• Limited Operating History – As a newer agency, Alcea has a shorter track record compared to more established competitors.
• Smaller Scale Operations – The boutique model means fewer resources and potentially longer timelines compared to larger agencies with bigger surrogate networks.

Who Alcea Surrogacy is Ideal For

5. Growing Generations – Best for Intended Parents with a High Budget

Growing Generations caters to intended parents who want premium, comprehensive service packages and has earned its place among the most reputable surrogacy agencies by serving high-end clientele with extensive customization options.

Investment Range: $200,000-$500,000+ depending on package selection

Key Advantages

• Complete Reproductive Services – The agency offers extensive egg and sperm donor programs alongside surrogacy, providing comprehensive solutions for complex fertility needs.
• Premium Service Packages – Growing Generations provides white-glove service with extensive customization options for intended parents who want maximum support and choice.

Considerations

• Significant Financial Investment – The agency’s comprehensive services come with premium pricing that puts them out of reach for many intended parents.
• Extended Timeline Requirements – Wait times typically range 12-18 months, requiring patience from intended parents eager to move forward.
• Screening Process Timing – Some reports indicate surrogates may not complete psychological screening until after initial matching, potentially creating delays or complications.

Who Growing Generations is Ideal For

Why Your Agency Choice Matters More Than You Think

Selecting among the most reputable surrogacy agencies isn’t just about finding someone to facilitate a transaction, it’s about choosing a partner who will guide you through one of the most emotionally complex and legally intricate processes in reproductive medicine.

The agency you choose will directly impact your timeline to parenthood, your stress levels throughout the journey, and ultimately, your entire experience of bringing your child into the world.

Your Time Is Precious

After potentially years of fertility struggles, intended parents have often exhausted their patience and emotional reserves. An agency with a 1-4 month wait time versus one with 18+ month delays can mean the difference between holding your baby next year versus waiting another two years.

When you’ve already been trying to conceive for years, every additional month of waiting carries profound emotional weight.

Financial Protection Is Non-Negotiable

Surrogacy represents one of the largest financial investments most families will ever make, often requiring loans, liquidating savings, or borrowing against retirement funds.

Agencies with robust financial protection programs can be the difference between a smooth journey and devastating financial loss if complications arise. The wrong choice could mean losing your entire investment with no baby to show for it.

Full-Service Support Is Essential

Surrogacy involves coordinating multiple specialists: reproductive endocrinologists, attorneys, mental health professionals, insurance specialists and medical coordinators.

When you’re juggling the emotional demands of surrogacy with your regular life responsibilities, having one trusted partner manage all the moving pieces isn’t just convenient, it’s vital for success.

Agencies that require you to coordinate separately with multiple providers create opportunities for miscommunication, delays, and costly mistakes that can derail your entire journey.

What Else to Consider When Choosing Your Agency

Beyond reputation, several additional factors should influence your decision among surrogacy agencies:

• Geographic Coverage – Different states have varying surrogacy laws, and agencies typically operate within specific regions. Ensure your chosen agency works in surrogacy-friendly states and understands the legal landscape where your surrogate will deliver.
• Surrogate Pool and Recruitment – Agencies with larger, pre-screened surrogate pools can typically match you faster. Inquire about their recruitment strategies and how they maintain relationships with surrogates to ensure a steady pipeline of qualified candidates.
• Communication Style and Support – Consider how the agency communicates during your initial consultation. The communication style you experience during the consultation process will likely continue throughout your journey.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

If you’re tired of waiting and ready to move forward with one of the most reputable surrogacy agencies that prioritizes speed, transparency and your peace of mind, it’s time to have a conversation with the right professionals.

Start with a free consultation to discuss your specific situation, timeline and goals. The best agencies will provide honest assessments of what you can expect and how they can support your unique journey to parenthood.

Ready to learn more? Contact the agencies that align with your priorities and take the first step toward bringing your baby home.